American Pie Co. interior
Sullivan's Hidden Gem

Every Slice Tells a Story Worth Savouring

From our wood-fired oven to your table — handcrafted pies, signature cocktails, and the kind of warmth that turns a Tuesday into a tradition.

Scroll
Fresh pie from the oven
Craft cocktails at the bar
Warm interior dining area
Handcrafted pie slice
Our Story

Born from Scratch,
Served with Soul

American Pie Co. isn't just a place to grab a slice — it's where Sullivan gathers. Our kitchen starts before dawn, rolling dough and preparing fillings that have been perfected over years of honest work.

By afternoon, the bar comes alive with craft cocktails designed to complement our pie program. Whether you're here for a quick café coffee or a long evening with friends, every visit is an invitation to slow down and savour what's real.

100%

Handcrafted Daily

12+

Signature Pies

4pm

Bar Comes Alive

Visit Us

Come Find Your Table

Address

1009 N Olive St
Sullivan, MO 63080

Phone

573-468-2050

Hours

Café: 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM
Bar: 4:00 PM – 11:00 PM
Closed Tuesdays

Reserve a Table

Fill out the form and we'll confirm your reservation within the hour.

Is this your business?This is my business